Search This Blog

Monday, September 10, 2012

How Do We Know?

This is the message given Sunday, September 9, 2012 in the Wheatland Parish.  The scripture used is 1 Peter 1:13-25.


            We are in the third week of United Methodism 101.  We’ve talked a little about the history of the United Methodist Church and we’ve talked a little about the organizational structure of the United Methodist Church.  I hope you’ve found that interesting, but some of you are probably wondering when we’re going to get to the good stuff.  When are we going to talk about things that really affect our lives?
           
Well, we’re going to get into that today.  What we’re going to talk about is how, as United Methodists, we decide what we believe.  That’s an important thing to talk about, because God created us with brains.  God did that for a reason.  God expects us to use those brains God gave us.
           
That’s part of our Wesleyan heritage, too.  That’s why Wesley emphasized studying the Bible.  He did not want people to trust someone else to tell them what the Bible says.  He did not even want them to trust him to tell them.  He wanted them to read the Bible for themselves, and make their own decisions about faith.

That’s why we don’t have a United Methodist catechism, like some denominations have.  We don’t have a laundry list of things you have to agree that you believe in order to become part of the United Methodist Church.  If you look at the vows you take to become a member of the United Methodist Church, they say that you repent of your sins, you believe in God the Father, you believe in Jesus Christ, you believe in the Holy Spirit, and you profess the Christian faith.  You then promise to be loyal to the United Methodist Church and to support it.  That’s it.
           
Now, that obviously gives people a lot of discretion.  It does not mean, however, that United Methodists don’t believe in anything or that anything goes in the United Methodist Church.  So how does a United Methodist decide what he or she believes?
           
Well, in keeping with our name as United Methodists, we have a method for it.  We start with the Bible.  Here’s what our United Methodist Book of Discipline, which sets out the religious standards for the United Methodist Church, says about the Bible:

Scripture is the primary source and criterion for Christian doctrine.  Through Scripture the living Christ meets us in the experience of redeeming grace.  We are convinced that Jesus Christ is the living Word of God in our midst whom we trust in life and death.  The Biblical authors, illumined by the Holy Spirit, bear witness that in Christ the world is reconciled to God.  The Bible bears authentic testimony to God’s self-disclosure in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ as well as in God’s work of creation, in the pilgrimage of Israel, and in the Holy Spirit’s ongoing activity in human history…Our standards affirm the Bible as the source of all that is “necessary” and “sufficient” unto salvation and “is to be received through the Holy Spirit as the true rule and guide for faith and practice.”

Sounds simple, right?  The Bible is where we find out about God.  Well, it is simple, and it’s not simple.  The thing is that two people can read the same passage in the Bible and interpret it differently.  That’s not just true about the Bible, of course.  It’s true in just about every walk of life.  You see that in politics, you see it in law, you see it in everything.  We look at the same words, or the same set of facts, and we reach different conclusions.  In the case of the Bible, I would not even be able to begin to count the number of books that have been written to try to explain what it “really” means.

There’s another aspect, too, of course.  The Bible is a wonderful book, and I don’t mean to come across as criticizing it, but the Bible does not cover every possible aspect of life on earth.  There’s no way it could.  Life on earth is too complex for that.  The Bible gives us standards and guidelines, but we have to apply those standards and guidelines to our lives.

Studying the Bible is still very important, of course.  The point is that we cannot just say “read the Bible” as the answer to every question of faith that might come up.  That’s our starting point, but it’s not our ending point.

So, how do we interpret the Bible to get the answers we need?  In United Methodism, we use three things.  One of them is tradition.

Now, remember what we are and are not talking about here.  We’re talking theology.  We’re talking about what we believe about God.  We’re not talking about how we conduct the worship service or what style of music we use or anything like that.  We’re talking about what the church has traditionally believed about God and about how we are to live our lives so that we can serve God.

Obviously, tradition is not the be-all and end-all.  Again, we first look to scripture.  Also, tradition is not always right.  For example, at one time, religious tradition was that women could not be pastors.  United Methodists don’t believe that now. 

So, in saying that we use tradition to interpret the Bible, we are not saying that we should slavishly follow tradition.  On the other hand, traditions generally develop for reasons.  Before we throw out those traditions, we need to look at how they got started in the first place.  In other words, we need to respect tradition without being completely bound by it.

Another thing we use to interpret the Bible is reason.  It gets back to that thing about God expecting us to use the brains we were given.  “Reason” does not just include our own personal knowledge, of course.  As we said earlier, many people have used their sense of reason to try to understand the Bible.  We should read their opinions, too, and see if they make sense.  We should apply our own reason to the reasoning of others.

Finally, we interpret the Bible through experience.  Again, this does not just mean our own personal experience, although it certainly includes that.  The thing is that none of us can live long enough, or do enough things, to experience all the things that a human being can experience.  We probably would not want to if we could.  We should use the experiences of others, as well as our own experience, to interpret the Bible correctly.

Here’s what makes all this tricky.  The traditions some of you grew up with are different from mine.  Your sense of reason will sometimes tell you different things than my sense of reason does.  Your experiences are different from mine, and will lead you to a different way of looking at life than my experiences will.  In other words, even if we all use reason, tradition, and experience to interpret the Bible, our interpretations of the Bible will be different.

And you know what?  That’s okay.  Because remember what we said last week?  United Methodists are a connectional people.  We have conferences.  We talk to each other.  We listen to each other.  Or at least, we’re supposed to.

United Methodists don’t say we all have to agree on everything in order to worship God together.  God did not create us to all be the same.  God created each one of us to be different, with different ideas and different opinions.  That way, we can learn from each other.

Look at it this way:  How can we learn anything from someone who agrees with us all the time?  We cannot.  We learn by talking with people who disagree with us and listening to what they have to say.  Maybe we’ll change our minds.  If not, we’ll at least have had to think about why we believe the way we do.  And so will they.  And we’ll all learn, and we’ll all get closer to God.

So, if you disagree with something I say in one of my sermons, or something I write in the newsletter, or something I suggest the church should do, that’s okay.  You don’t have to agree with everything I say or write or do to be part of our church.  You don’t have to agree with everything anybody says or writes or does to be part of our church.

Anyone is welcome to be part of the United Methodist Church.  If you want to be a member, all you need to do is repent of your sins, believe in God the Father, believe in Jesus Christ, believe in the Holy Spirit, profess the Christian faith, and promise to be loyal to and support the United Methodist Church.  That’s it.

United Methodists don’t claim to have all the answers.  Faith is not about knowing all the answers.  Faith is about believing in God, accepting Jesus Christ as our Savior, and allowing the Holy Spirit to work in our lives.  If we do that, God will take care of the rest.

No comments:

Post a Comment