Search This Blog

Saturday, September 30, 2017

When God Says No

This is the message given in the United Methodist churches of the Wheatland Parish on Sunday, October 1, 2017.  The Bible verses used are Luke 23:1-12.


            We continue looking at the last days of Jesus’ life on earth.  Jesus has been betrayed.  He’s been arrested.  He’s been questioned by the high priest.  Now, he’s been brought before the Roman governor, Pontius Pilate.
            A Roman governor, at that time, served at the pleasure of the Roman emperor.  In other words, the Roman emperor could appoint anyone he wanted to serve as a governor, for any reason or no reason.  And the Roman emperor could remove any governor and appoint a different one, again for any reason or no reason.  
So, if you were a Roman governor, one of your main concerns was to keep the emperor happy.  And what was the best way to do that.  Well, two things.  One, make sure that money keeps flowing to the emperor’s treasury.  In other words, make sure all the taxes from your area that are supposed to go to Rome get to Rome.  And if you can send a little bit more than that, well, that would be appreciated.  Two, keep the peace.  Keep things under control.  Don’t let there be any unrest, don’t let the people get stirred up to the point where they try something.  Don’t make Rome have to send troops to your area to calm things down.  Keep them calm yourself.
So, knowing that, what are the two things the chief priests, the people out to get Jesus, tell Pilate?  First, they tell him Jesus opposes paying taxes to Rome.  Second, they tell him Jesus is getting the people all stirred up and things might get out of control.  The chief priests tell those things to Pilate precisely because they know those are the things that will get Pilate’s attention.
So, you’re Pilate.  You have the chief priests telling you these things about Jesus, and you’re concerned.  But on the other hand, you’ve heard that this Jesus guy has quite a following.  If you come out too strongly against him, maybe his followers will get even more out of control.  What do you do?
Well, you’re a politician, so you look for a way to pass the buck.  And Pilate thought he’d found one.  He finds out that Jesus is from Galilee, and he says, well, I’m the governor for Jerusalem. Herod’s the governor for Galilee.  I’ll let Herod deal with him.  And that’s the part of the story I want to talk about.
Now, this is not the same Herod the wise men talked to in the Christmas story.  This Herod, we’re told, had heard about Jesus and was eager to see him.  Why?  Because he was hoping Jesus would work some sort of miracle.  He wanted to see a show.  You can just imagine Herod pleading with Jesus to work a miracle, suggesting things he might do.  He had no interest in actually learning about Jesus or following him.  He was treating Jesus like a magician who was supposed to do tricks for him.  And when Jesus refused to do that, Herod sent him back to Pilate.  When he saw Jesus was not going to perform on command, Herod lost interest.
Now, when you put it like that, what Herod did sounds pretty crass.  It sounds really disrespectful of Jesus.  How could he treat Jesus like that?  How could he act like Jesus was one of his court jesters, someone who’s only worth was to entertain Herod?  How could Herod act so arrogantly to the divine Son of God?  You and I would never do anything like that.
And yet.  We’re tempted to.  We’re tempted to all the time.  And sometimes we give in to that temptation.  Not in that exact way, of course.  Not as obviously and crudely as that.
But think about it.  Have you ever been in a tough spot and asked God to bail you out of it?  Or, have you ever prayed for God to do something specific, and been disappointed when God did not do it?
Now, I’m not saying we do this just out of a desire to see God perform a magic trick.  We turn to God in this way for lots of reasons, and sometimes they’re very good reasons, or at least they seem that way to us.  Sometimes we’re convinced that what we want would be a good thing, not just for ourselves, but for everybody involved.  Sometimes we sincerely believe that what we want is, in fact, God’s will.  And of course, at other times, we turn to God in this way because we’re desperate.  We’re in a spot where we see no way out and have nowhere else to turn.  And of course, there can be lots of other reasons we pray this way, too.
But for whatever reason, we pray for God to do some specific thing.  And sometimes, God does those things.  But sometimes, God does not.  And so, the question is, how do we react to that?  How do we react when, maybe with nothing but the best of intentions, we ask God to do something and God does not do it?
Well, we’re probably disappointed.  And that’s pretty natural.  But what then?  Once we get over our disappointment, or at least get reconciled to it, then what?  Where do we go from there?
We saw what Herod did.  Herod completely lost interest in Jesus.  Herod decided that if Jesus was not going to do what he wanted, then he wanted nothing to do with Jesus.  He sent Jesus away and essentially decided that Jesus was never going to be a part of his life again.
But of course, Herod never really believed in Jesus in the first place.  He was curious about him, he’d heard some things, but he never actually believed.  And in fact, it appears that there was no chance that he ever would believe.  Again, he was not interested in faith.  He wanted to see a show.
You and I, presumably, do believe.  Or at least we’re interested.  I don’t know why we’d be here, in church, if we did not.  But what is it that we actually believe in?  Do we believe in a God who’s supposed to do what we want, at least if we ask sincerely and with good intentions?  Or do we believe in something more than that?
Because here’s what makes this hard.  A lot of us have prayed for very serious and important things.  The restoration of a relationship.  The healing of a loved one.  Protection and safety in a frightening situation.  All sorts of things that are very serious and very important.  And again, sometimes God does what we want.  But sometimes God does not.  So the question is, can we accept that?  Can we accept that God heard our sincere and heartfelt prayer, that God considered what we asked for with the best of intentions and with love in our hearts, and said no?  Can we continue to have faith in God when God does not do what we know God could do and what we truly believe God should do?
We know what the answer should be.  And it’s easy to say it when we’re not faced with it.  But I know some of you have been faced with it.  Some of you may be facing it now.  And if not, then at some point in your life you will.  It happens to all of us eventually, where we ask for God to do something, something that’s very important to us, something that we believe with all our hearts is the right and best thing, and God says no.
That’s when we find out how real our faith is.  That’s when we find out if we truly have faith in God.  When God says no to something that’s very important to us, something we think would be the best thing not just for us but for everyone, that’s when we find out if we have enough faith in God to trust that God’s way is better than our way.  When we’re convinced that our plan is the best plan, when we cannot see that there could possibly be a better plan, can we still believe that somehow, God must have a better plan?  Do we trust God enough to believe that?
Again, we know what the answer should be.  But this is not a question we can answer with our heads.  It’s a question we have to answer with our hearts.  It does not matter what we should believe.  What matters is what we do believe.  It does not matter that we should have faith and that we should trust God.  What matters is whether we do have faith and do trust God.
            Now, if you struggle with this, it’s okay.  This is not an easy thing to deal with.  God knows that.  I have to think there are times when it’s hard for God to say no, even when God knows that’s the right answer.  Because in these situations, God knows how we’re going to feel when God says no.  God knows how much we’re going to hurt.  God does not want us to hurt.  But God knows that God’s plan is better than what we want, even if we cannot see how it possibly could be.  And so God has to say no, even knowing the hurt it’s going to cause us.
            Over the last few weeks, we’ve talked a lot about aligning our hearts with God’s heart.  We’ve talked a lot about doing God’s will rather than our own.  But this is where it gets real.  This is where we find out just how real our faith in God truly is.  This is where we find out if we can really mean those words we pray in the Lord’s Prayer every Sunday:  “Thy will be done”.
            It’s a question each of us has to answer for ourselves.  I’ll be happy to talk with you about it, of course.  If you’re struggling with something, please contact me.  I’ll do anything I can to be there for you and help you work through this.  And I’m sure there are other people who would do that, too.
            But ultimately, we each have to answer the question for ourselves.  May we get whatever help we need, and do whatever is necessary, to keep our faith strong, even when God says no.


No comments:

Post a Comment