Search This Blog

Saturday, April 4, 2015

Who's Responsible?

This is the Good Friday message in the United Methodist churches of the Wheatland Parish.  The Bible verses used are John 19:1-30.

As I was preparing this message and looking once again at the story of Jesus’ death, I started to think about the people who were directly responsible for it.  I mean, we know it was God’s plan and it was necessary for our salvation, but still, there were people, human beings, who did things that caused Jesus to die.  And they were not serving God by doing that, at least not consciously.  They were serving themselves and their own interests. 
There was Pilate, of course.  We heard quite a bit about him in our reading for today.  Pilate gets his share of the blame for Jesus’ death, and rightly so.  But you know, Pilate had nothing in particular against Jesus.  He really did not care much about Jesus one way or the other.  Pilate was the Roman governor.  He had no reason to be concerned with this Jewish guy.  He was just trying to keep the peace.  He’d have been happy to let Jesus go if that would’ve made people happy.  In fact, he tried to do that.  And as you heard, even Jesus said there were people who were guilty of greater sins in this story than Pilate was.
There was Herod.  Herod does not appear in the gospel of John, but Luke tells us that Pilate sent Jesus to Herod, hoping Herod would take care of the situation.  Herod really did not care about Jesus one way or the other, either.  He’d heard about Jesus and was hoping to see Jesus perform some sort of sign, some sort of miracle, but when Jesus did not do that Herod lost interest and sent Jesus back to Pilate.  Herod deserves some blame, because he could’ve kept Jesus from dying and did not, but he’s really a pretty minor actor in this story.
There was Judas.  Judas, of course, betrayed Jesus.  He went and reported to the Jewish authorities where Jesus was going to be.  But Judas just helped set things in motion.  He deserves his share of the blame, too.  No doubt about it.  But he did not exactly act alone.  In fact, without the actions of lots of other people, what Judas did would’ve made no difference at all.
There was Caiaphas.  Caiaphas did not show up in our reading for today—he appears earlier.  Caiaphas was the Jewish high priest.  He definitely was one of the ones who wanted Jesus dead.  He was one of the priests plotting against Jesus.  He may have even been the one Judas reported to and the one who sent the soldiers to the Garden of Gethsemane, we don’t know.  We know Jesus was taken first to Annas and then to Caiaphas, and it was only after that, that he was taken to Pilate.  So Caiaphas certainly deserves his share of the blame, too.
But even though Caiaphas was the high priest, he could never have done it by himself.  As I said, he plotted with other priests to do this.  He had to have them on his side.  If the other priests had opposed him, Jesus would never have been arrested, much less killed.
Those are the only people who are named as having a role in Jesus death.  The rest are just named as groups.  They’re referred to as “the soldiers” or “the priests” or “the Sanhedrin” or “the crowd”.  We don’t know anything about the individuals who were part of those groups.  But each of those individuals share some blame in Jesus’ death, too.  And we have no idea who they may have been.
And maybe that’s part of the point.  Because it was not one person who was responsible for Jesus’ death.  It was everybody.  Everybody who was around there, anyway.  Every one of the soldiers.  Every one of the priests.  Every one of the Sanhedrin.  Everyone in the crowd.  Every one of those people who shouted “Crucify” deserves part of the blame for Jesus’ death.
Now, that’s not to say that each and every one of those people wanted Jesus killed.  We don’t know that.  But we have no record of anyone trying to stop it.  We have no record of anyone standing up and saying “No!  This is wrong!  We should not be doing this!”  If anyone was opposed to Jesus being killed, they either kept it to themselves or eventually decided to go along with it, just like Pilate did.  Not even the disciples would stand up and try to stop it.  Judas betrayed Jesus, Simon Peter denied knowing him, and the rest appear to have run away and hid.  No one was willing to stand with Jesus.
Maybe there was nothing they could’ve done.  Maybe if someone had stood up, it would’ve made no difference.  Some of them probably told themselves that.  And maybe it was even true.  But we’ll never know, because we have no record that anyone ever tried.  We have no record that anyone attempted to do anything for Jesus.  In the end, it was just Jesus, by himself, against the entire known world.  In the end, it was just Jesus, alone.
Would we be any different, do you think?  If you or I had been one of the soldiers, or one of the priests, or one of the crowd?  Would we have stood up and said, “No, this is wrong, we should not be doing this?”  Or would we have kept our opinions to ourselves and decided to just go along with it, to stay out of trouble?
I see no reason to think that we would’ve been better than the people in the crowd.  I certainly see no reason to think I would’ve been.  And I especially see no reason to think I’d have been better than Simon Peter or the rest of the disciples.  I’d love to think I would’ve tried to do something, but to be honest, I don’t think I probably would have.
Everybody was responsible for Jesus’ death.  But you know, it seems like maybe it could not help but be that way.  It seems like maybe that was part of God’s plan, too.  After all, Jesus died to take the punishment of the sins of all of us.  God knew all of us would be responsible for Jesus’ death.  God knew we’d all need saving, every one of us.  And so God planned for it.
And you know, if we really thought that we’d be better than the crowd, that we’d be better than the disciples, if we really thought we’d be the ones who actually would’ve stood up and done something, we might also think that we did not need saving.  We might think that Jesus did not die for us, that we were so good that we did not need forgiveness and salvation.  And we might not take advantage of the incredible gift of salvation that God gave us through Jesus’ death.
But it’s because we realize that we are no better than the disciples that we come to this Good Friday service.  I mean, it’s kind of strange thing, don’t you think?  Can you think of any other faith that looks at the death of its founder as something to celebrate?  I cannot.  And yet, as Christians, that’s exactly what we do.  We celebrate Good Friday.  We celebrate the killing of Jesus.  That must seem so odd to non-Christians, if they really think about it.  It must seem so strange to them that we would celebrate the killing of Jesus Christ, the person we claim as our Savior, the person we claim to follow, the person for who our faith is named.
But we do celebrate it.  We do celebrate Jesus being killed.  We don’t celebrate because we’re happy that Jesus was killed.  We celebrate because we’re grateful that Jesus was willing to die.  We celebrate Good Friday not because of what happened, but because of what it means.
We celebrate the death of Jesus because we know he died for us.  We celebrate the death of Jesus because we know that it was not a permanent death.  We celebrate the death of Jesus because we know that Jesus defeated death and rose again.  And we celebrate the death of Jesus because we know that Jesus did not just defeat death for himself.  He defeated death for each one of us, too.  Every one of us is responsible for Jesus’ death.  And yet Jesus rose again, and defeated death, and took the punishment for the sins, of every one of us.
In a little while, we’ll leave here.  We’ll go on about our business, going wherever we go and doing whatever we do.  And before long, everyone will have forgotten everything I’ve said here today.  I don’t mean that as a criticism of you, or of me for that matter.  It’s just the way it is.  I’ve heard lots of Good Friday messages over the years, and I don’t know that I can remember anything from any of them.  I don’t know that I particularly remember any of the Good Friday messages I’ve given myself.  I don’t expect this message to have any more impact than any of those did.
            But I hope you’ll think about Good Friday and what it means for us.  Each one of us was responsible for Jesus being killed.  And Jesus willingly allowed it to happen, so that each one of us would be saved.  And that truly is something to celebrate.


No comments:

Post a Comment