Below is the text of the message given in the Wheatland Parish on Sunday, November 4, 2012. The Scripture used is John 9:1-7.
Today is
the last entry in our current sermon series “Does God?”
Think of what
we’ve talked about in this sermon series. We’ve said God loves us and
cares about us, God answers our prayers, God has a plan for our lives, and that
God wants us to enjoy life and be happy. So here’s the question: If all that’s true, why do so many bad
things happen?
There’s no
question that they do. Just this week
we saw the destruction caused by Hurricane Sandy. We’ve had plenty of
examples of bad things happening right here in our community recently, too.
When these things
happen, it’s pretty natural to start asking, “Where’s God? Where’s God in all
this stuff? Does God cause it? Even if God does not cause it, could
God not stop it? If so, why does God not stop it? And if not, is
God really an almighty, all-powerful God?”
These are not new
questions, of course. They go back thousands of years. The early Hebrews asked that question, and
they thought they had an answer for it. They said, look, God is just and
fair, so we get what we deserve. If good things happen to you, it means
you must be a righteous person, and you did something to deserve having them
happen. If you bad things happen to you, it means you must have sinned;
you did something to deserve having bad things happen. Simple.
The trouble was
that people looked around and saw that did not seem to be true. There were too
many times when it seemed like people who were not good people, people who lied
and cheated and stole, had wealth and happiness on earth, even though they did
not deserve it. There were also too many times when it seemed like people
who were really good people, who loved the Lord and who did their best to serve
God and follow all the rules, still had all kinds of bad things happen to them,
even though they did not deserve it, either.
This is what the
whole book of Job is about. If you remember, Job was considered to be the
most righteous man on the face of the earth. He seemed to have been
rewarded for that, because he had great wealth, a large family, and all kinds
of happiness. Then, all of a sudden, for no apparent reason, it was all
taken away from him. He lost his possessions, all his children died, and he
completely lost his health. And he had no idea why, because he did
nothing to deserve having this happen.
Then Job’s friends
came, and they refused to believe him. They keep telling him, look, you
must have done something wrong. This has to be a punishment from
God. You need to confess your sin and
repent. But Job kept saying, “I’ve not done anything to deserve this.
This has happened to me for no reason, and I don’t understand it.”
This idea that bad
things happen because God is punishing us persists. You can see it in our
reading from John today. Jesus and the disciples are walking along, and
they see a blind man. The first thing the disciples ask Jesus is “Who
sinned to make this man blind?” They just assumed that this man’s
blindness must have been a punishment. And even though Jesus said that’s
not the way it works, there are plenty of people who still believe that, even
today.
There are, of
course, times when God makes us live with the consequences of our actions.
That’s where another explanation for bad things happening on earth comes
in. It says that God gave us free will, and that has to include the
freedom to do wrong, or our will would not truly be free. Whatever we do,
good or bad, affects more than just ourselves.
Our actions affect other people, too, sometimes in ways that we don’t
think about or even know about. The things I do affect you, and the
things you do affect me. So when you and I do wrong, bad things are going to
happen. They may happen to us, or they may happen to others, but bad
things are going to happen. That means sometimes bad things are going to
happen to us, not because we did anything to deserve them, but because someone
else did something that made them happen.
One of the things
I always think about, when I think about this topic, is my nephew, Wade.
Wade was killed in a car accident several years ago, just a week short of
his fourteenth birthday. Wade was
riding to school with his mom and another driver ran a stop sign and smashed
into the car, killing him instantly.
Wade’s death was,
of course, the result of the actions of the other driver. That’s not to
say the other driver was evil or anything, but he made a mistake, and that
mistake had consequences. It took Wade’s life, and it permanently changed
the lives of everyone else in both of the families involved.
Now, I don’t think
for a minute that this accident was a punishment from God, nor do I think that
God in any way caused it. Still, I
wonder, even if God did not cause it, could God not have prevented it?
And if so, why did God not prevent it? After all, it would not have
taken much. If either driver had left home a few seconds sooner, or a few
seconds later, the cars would not have collided. If either driver had
driven even one mile per hour slower, or one mile per hour faster, the cars
would not have collided. Surely God, the almighty, all-powerful God,
could have intervened and changed things so that the accident would not happen.
But God did not do that. The accident did happen, and Wade did die.
And I really don’t understand why.
Then, too, there
are all the natural disasters that happen all around the world, like the one we
just saw this week. Nobody does anything to cause those things.
Those things have been going on for thousands of years, and there’s
nothing any humans have done to cause them. They just happen. They
happen, and some people lose everything, and some of them die. And we
don’t understand why.
I referenced the
book of Job earlier. Job constantly asks that question of why. He
asks it of his friends, and they say it’s Job’s fault, but that’s not true.
So, Job asks the question of God. He asks it several times, and
finally, near the end of the book, God responds. God’s response, though, does not answer Job’s question. God
does not tell Job why. Instead, God says, essentially, that we’re not
supposed to understand why. We’re supposed to have faith. We’re
supposed to believe. We’re supposed to trust that God is in control, and
that things will ultimately go the way they’re supposed to, even if we don’t
understand all the things that happen along the way.
We’re not really
very satisfied with that answer. I certainly am not. I have a hard
time accepting it, and I’m not sure how to respond to it. If we’re not
going to be told why things happen, it seems like we should at least be told
why we’re not going to be told why. But God does not tell us that,
either.
In thinking about
this, let’s look at today’s scripture reading from the book of John again.
I think one of the reasons this story is in the Bible is to show us how
we’re supposed to respond to this whole question of bad things happening.
There’s a man who was born blind. Now, I’m sure blindness is a
tough thing now and I’m not trying to minimize it causes at all, but two
thousand years ago it was a lot worse. Back then, there was basically
nothing a blind person could do but sit by the side of the road and beg, hoping
someone would come by and give them something. Hope to get enough to
survive today so that you can get up and try to survive tomorrow.
So, Jesus and the
disciples are walking by, and they see this man. And what do the
disciples do? They immediately ask “Why? Why was this man born
blind? We know somebody must have sinned, but who was it? Was it
the man himself, or was it his parents?”
Does Jesus tell
them why the man was born blind? Not really. He says, instead, that
this man’s blindness is going to be used to reveal the greatness of God.
Then, Jesus heals the man.
By asking why, the
disciples did what it comes natural to us to do. The thing is, though,
that while it may be natural for us to ask why, it’s a question we’re never
going to be able to answer, at least not in this life. God did not answer
it for Job. Jesus did not answer it for the disciples. And nobody’s
likely to answer it for us, either.
What Jesus did,
though, shows us how we should respond to the bad things that we see in the
world. Jesus did not stop to discuss the why. Instead, Jesus did
something about it. Jesus healed the man. Jesus did not get
into a theological discussion about why such a bad thing should have happened
to someone who, for all we know, may have been as faithful and upright as it’s
possible for a person to be. Instead of discussing why this bad thing
should have happened to this man, Jesus took the bad thing away. He
healed him. Through that healing, God’s greatness was revealed.
I think Jesus was
telling us through this that when we ask why, we’re asking the wrong question.
The question is not, why do bad things happen? The question is, how
are we going to respond when they do? Instead of sitting there looking at
a situation and asking “Why did this happen?”, what we’re supposed to ask is
“What can I do about it?”
You and I, of
course, are not Jesus. We don’t have the power to heal someone by rubbing
mud on their eyes and having them wash it off. Our job, though, is the
same. John Wesley has a famous quote about what that job is. He
said that we are supposed to do all the good we can, by all the means we can,
in all the ways we can, in all the places we can, at all the times we can, to
all the people we can, as long as ever we can.
I don’t know why
the world is the way it is. I’ll probably never know. I know,
though, that when bad things happen, it’s not because God is punishing us.
I also know that, when bad things happen, God does not want us to waste a
lot of time wondering why. Instead, God
wants us to get off our rear ends and do something about it. We may not
be able to solve everything, but that’s okay. God does not expect us to
solve everything. All God asks, as Wesley said, is that we do whatever we
can.
Even if there’s very little that we can do, it’s still
important that we do the little that we can, and trust God to do the rest.
And sometimes, with God’s help, what seems like a little to us may make
more difference than we ever imagine. When we do our best to follow God’s
will, God’s greatness can be revealed through us, just as Jesus said.